Est-il bénéfique ou nuisible?

BÉNÉFIQUE NUISIBLE

Translate to other languages

English Dutch French German Italian Portuguese Russian Spanish

PSA: School Inequality in Neighboring Zip Codes

Contexte
This is a piece of positive propaganda produced by the National Education Association to illustrate the difference between 2 schools illustrating the inequalities between poor and rich schools.
Technique utilisée
Respond to Audience Needs
Pourquoi est-ce un message d'influence?
This activates emotion and respond to the feelings of audiences who may be able to relate to one or other of the perspectives.

Comments

  1. user-avatar
    karynoni
    mer 18/11/2015 - 01:42
    karynoni
    My rating compared fairly well with others, though more persons thought it was more beneficial than the group I fell in. I agree that it wold activate a response in those who may have experienced difficulties in school. I am not sure it would appeal to others. So although a positive piece of propaganda, I am not sure it is quite effective.
  1. user-avatar
    Berrystella
    mer 18/11/2015 - 23:46
    Berrystella
    Yes it activated positive emotion and in a general sense is drawing a limited attention to different schools and what they have funding for.
  1. user-avatar
    emily85
    jeu 19/11/2015 - 07:03
    emily85
    My rating was with the top rated group- beneficial. I think this ad really pulls on the audiences feelings. This is positive propaganda.
  1. user-avatar
    Nichoals RIchie
    sam 21/11/2015 - 10:58
    Nichoals RIchie
    My rating was vastly different than everyone else's. Everyone seemed to be beneficial more than anything else, which makes sense because it is not really harmful
  1. user-avatar
    Kathi
    dim 22/11/2015 - 06:11
    Kathi
    This definitely activates emotion when you watch it. It would be helpful if a solution to the problem was suggested. I agree with everything they said, but what I can do about it?
  1. user-avatar
    Zachary J. Davis
    dim 22/11/2015 - 07:11
    Zachary J. Davis
    This particular propaganda points out that there is a such thing as class segregation. Different locations tend to have different opportunities, and that is a bad thing. However, the ad does not offer any tangible solutions, nor does it point out any ways we can--as a society--get involved in the change. It benefits because it points out a problem, but fails because it does not offer a solution... it only theorizes the possibilities.

    In addition, it does not offer any empirical information that may benefit its cause, which leads me to believe that they did not bother to find any.
  1. user-avatar
    Jyba
    dim 22/11/2015 - 07:37
    Jyba
    Even though I rated this as beneficial, I also think that it can be somewhat harmful. What I mean by this, is that students who attend a "poor" school may use this as an excuse not to try hard because either way he or she is bound to fail.
  1. user-avatar
    Justin Reilly
    dim 22/11/2015 - 10:22
    Justin Reilly
    I think this video illustrates a common narrative in the American education system that is often swept under the rug or otherwise overlooked.
  1. user-avatar
    God
    ven 11/12/2015 - 20:05
    God
    I didn't think it was harmful because all they did was talk about where they grew up
  1. user-avatar
    Hnhs
    ven 11/12/2015 - 20:07
    Hnhs
    this video was beneficial to show the differences of choices and how they impact you
  1. user-avatar
    Sarah
    mer 20/04/2016 - 02:17
    Sarah
    I think that this piece of propaganda is very beneficial and gets across a powerful message. Schools for young people of all ages can make or break a young persons life.
  1. user-avatar
    CB
    jeu 29/03/2018 - 21:59
    CB
    This article appeals to the viewers' need for a good education

Share Your Ideas

CAPTCHA
Image CAPTCHA
Saisir les caractères affichés dans l'image.
Cette question sert à vérifier si vous êtes un visiteur humain ou non afin d'éviter les soumissions de pourriel (spam) automatisées.